Guild Insurance

Customer Claim Satisfaction scores rise consistently year-on-year through the use of PeoplePulse surveying and reporting tools, helping Guild Insurance to create the ultimate personalised claims service.

 Executive Summary:

Established in 1963, Guild Insurance has grown from a small business focused purely on the pharmacy industry, into a multi-faceted business dedicated to protecting Australian professionals. Today, Guild Insurance offers its customers a variety of commercial and personal insurance products and legal support, with over 140 industry partnerships and 80,000 customers nationally.

PeoplePulse began working with Guild Insurance in 2013 to build their current Post Claims Customer Survey. It is now two years since the survey was launched online to their customers and as a result of the feedback, they have implemented changes to their claims process that have seen consistent year-on-year growth in customer satisfaction.

Loretta Redman, Claims Operations Manager at Guild Insurance said:

Our survey has enabled us to make our claims process more personalised than ever. We have been able to move our focus away from the process and make it more about the customer.

 Background Summary & Project Objectives:

Being a direct insurer, Guild Insurance’s customers and the experience they have when making a claim are central to the success of their business. Before they engaged PeoplePulse in 2013 they were running their own in-house survey process and mailing a hard copy Post Claims Survey to their customers. This meant they relied on customers returning the surveys via post and then manually collated the data for reporting. It was a very manual and time consuming task.

Loretta Redman explained:

Whilst the existing survey allowed us to gather insights about customer experiences across different state locations, we could not easily filter down or compare the data by different customer groups or types of claims and view the results for each step in the claim process. Because of this limitation in the reporting, we could not confidently identify what we did well and what we needed to improve on.

Moving forward the Guild Insurance claims team wanted:

  • To create more specific questions to gain a greater insight into the type of service their customers expect across their three major product lines.
  • To have an accurate tool to analyse their claims performance at each customer touch point and enable them to move from “we think” to “we know” what their customers see as our areas of improvement.
  • A reporting capability that quickly and easily breaks down the survey results in different ways and also shows trends over time.
  • To use the feedback to implement changes to enhance their claims service and be able to monitor their success through the results.

The Solution:

The assigned PeoplePulse Project Manager worked with Guild Insurance to develop their survey questions and created a slightly different survey for each major product line. Each survey contains some generic questions (used across all three surveys) and some questions specific to the product line itself.

The generic questions are ‘tagged’ to become part of a special PeoplePulse generated ‘Aggregate Report’, meaning the survey results for each of these generic questions can be combined across all three products lines to give an overall real time result, or the results of each product line can be compared against each other side-by-side.

Each product line has its own tailored survey invitation which is further personalised with the customer’s claim details, so the customer knows exactly what claim the survey was in relation to. When the surveys are sent out via email, the invites are ‘pre-loaded’ with customer data (such as Claims Type, Customer Group, Product Class etc.). This data is used to ‘segment and compare’ the results of the survey in various different ways via the self-service real time reporting tools available within PeoplePulse.

Real time alerts:

In addition, PeoplePulse suggested that Guild ask their customers at the end of the survey if they would like to have their survey responses followed up a Claims Representative. If the customers selects ‘yes’ then a full survey summary (including the customer’s preferred contact details) is automatically emailed to both the Claims Operations Manager and the Claims Service Team, so they can quickly and easily call the customer and follow up their survey responses.

Project Outcomes:

  • The Claims Team can quickly and easily extract data straight from PeoplePulse and share internally with various internal teams o a regular basis.
  • Key themes can be easily identified which enables Guild to quickly implement improvement ideas.
  • The Claims Team are interacting personally with customers that have completed the survey where results are both high or low, or when they have specifically requested a call back. This ensures any issues can be quickly addressed.

Loretta Redman commented:

Our customers love knowing that we have actually read their survey and we are listening to them.

Catholic Healthcare

PeoplePulse helps Catholic Healthcare achieve a record completion rate for their Staff Engagement Survey.

 Background Summary & Project Objectives:

Catholic Healthcare offers a diverse range of services through residential aged care, healthcare and community services programs across NSW and south-east Queensland. The organisation has a head count of nearly 4000 employees.

Their HR team wanted to run a staff engagement survey to understand their employees’ beliefs about the organisation across a range of topics. They also wanted to set some baseline results against which they planned to develop HR strategies to further increase staff engagement levels.

This was not the first time the HR Team had run a staff engagement survey but they felt that previous surveys were too lengthy and the reporting was too complicated. Their primary objectives for this survey was to keep it simple, make it meaningful and ensure the outcomes actionable. Being a fairly small HR Team, they also wanted a solution that was not onerous to execute from a time and resource perspective.

According to Human Resources Manager, Jill Paull:

“Catholic Healthcare chose to work with PeoplePulse because of the simplicity of the self-managed reporting tools available to analyse the data. We also liked that we could run the survey using both an online version sent to staff via email invites, in addition to using a paper survey for staff without an email address.”

 Key Employee Engagement Themes:

This is how Catholic Healthcare’s HR Team defined staff engagement and what it means to have an “engaged employee”:

  • Staff engagement refers to the ongoing relationship between an organisation and its employees
  • The level of emotional commitment an employee has to the organisation and its goals
  • An “engaged employee“ genuinely cares about their work and the organisation

PeoplePulse worked with Catholic Healthcare to develop customised content for the survey which resulted in 25 key questions across 6 main themes. A focus was made on ensuring that every question in the survey had a clear purpose and could be easily understood and answered by employees at all levels.

The six themes comprised of:

  1. My Manager
  2. Satisfaction & Motivation
  3. Recognition and Reward
  4. Education & Safety
  5. Our Workplace Culture
  6. Overall Assessment of the Organisation

Catholic Healthcare

The Challenges:

One of the biggest challenges faced by the HR Team was reassuring employees that the survey results would remain strictly anonymous. This aspect of their survey is something that is crucial for the success of most staff engagement surveys to help ensure a high response rate is achieved. A number of actions were taken to try and mitigate this risk, including:

  • To help build trust and credibility, PeoplePulse suggested that Catholic Healthcare co-brand with the PeoplePulse logo and invite content to emphasise that the survey was being run by an independent, expert 3rd party.
  • PeoplePulse advised the use of ballot boxes at each Catholic Healthcare location and the appointment of a local ‘champion’ to empty the ballot box and send all the paper surveys to PeoplePulse once the survey had closed. PeoplePulse organised the data entry and secure document destruction of all the paper surveys once the project had come to an end.
  • PeoplePulse applied an anonymity setting to the survey reporting which prevented the HR Team from being able to view the results from any area of the organisation where less than a fixed number of completed surveys had been returned. This ensured that anonymity was always maintained.

Key Learnings & Project Outcomes:

  • The survey achieved a record 66% completion rate against a 49% and 54% completion rate in previous years.
  • Overall, Catholic Healthcare achieved some high scores for many of the key survey themes, which positively reinforced to staff and management that employee engagement initiatives were on the right track.
  • Where weaknesses were identified it validated with hard data the potential benefit of some of the planned workforce strategies the organisation had in mind.
  • The survey results were communicated back to staff by providing each manager (where enough surveys had been completed to ensure anonymity) a simple feedback report with just their results for each survey question.
  • Staff meetings were then arranged by the manager’s to discuss and review actions to be taken.
  • The feedback reports were also put up on staff notice boards for all employees to see and reinforce the benefits of participating.

What they said:

Commenting on the project, Jill Paull said:

“The co-branding helped increase credibility and we also ran a competition for the highest return rate per service line, which resulted in some sites with over 100 employees getting 100% return rate. We were very happy with the result. The relationship between PeoplePulse and Catholic healthcare was excellent and the methods used to distribute and control the survey went very smoothly.”

Given the success of the staff engagement survey, Catholic Healthcare are now working with PeoplePulse to develop an equally simple Employee Exit Survey & Employee Onboarding Survey, which will align with their staff engagement survey questions to provide even more understanding and evidence to support their employee attraction and retention strategies.

When asked what message Jill would like to give to other companies thinking about running a staff engagement survey, she commented:

“Take the time to think about the questions you are going to be asking and their relevance. Think about the outcomes that you want to achieve as you will need to take action on the feedback at the end but be open to changing your initial thoughts about what you want and be flexible. PeoplePulse’s guidance, patience and sense of humour really helped us come up with a survey that was effective and still delivered on our original objectives.”

The SEEK Experience

Seek logo - small

The Problem:

SEEK Limited is the operator of Australia and New Zealand’s largest and most successful Internet employment site – and In 2003 and early 2004, SEEK conducted an extensive research program across a range of clients, job seekers and internal staff and employed a US-based online survey tool. Whilst SEEK found the tool to be relatively inexpensive to operate, as SEEK developed more numerous and more complex survey projects, it became clear that the US software held limitations in significant areas:

  • survey functionality – the program offered limited flexibility in areas such as custom survey design, question limits, and attrition reporting,
  • while the duplication or modification of past surveys was feasible, it proved difficult and time-consuming,
  • US-based features built into the software tool, such as time zone settings, affected report accuracy, and
  • built-in branding for the software tool (including the phrase ‘Powered by..’) limited its use – and while not an obstacle for internal surveys, could not be used in professional external communication.

The software employed was effectively a ‘no frills’ survey tool that proved perfectly acceptable and easy to use for informal and simple survey work, but could not meet the demands of the more complex and professional research projects SEEK was developing.

SEEK required a solution that offered flexibility, the option to easily tailor and duplicate surveys and individual questions, and the ability to control branding to deliver a professional image in both internal and external research efforts.

The Solution:

Following extensive research of the Australian and international online survey market, SEEK selected the PeoplePulse survey tool from Quinntessential for the following reasons:

  • Product Flexibility – PeoplePulse is a comprehensive online survey tool that addresses the problems that SEEK were facing with the US-based tool. As a locally developed and hosted tool, it offers rich survey creation and reporting functionality, and this flexibility gave PeoplePulse a clear advantage over other similar online survey products.
  • Approach to new product development – From the outset, Quinntessential made it clear that they were happy to work with SEEK to customise the tool for SEEK’s unique needs. At their own expense, Quinntessential added new survey branching and skip logic functionality, added the ability to conduct ranking questions, and also added a new ‘cross tab’ report to the system to allow reporting and data analysis to be conducted online. These were all features that significantly enhanced the value of the tool for SEEK.
  • Responsive – Quinntessential was proactive, prompt and professional in all dealings with SEEK. SEEK’s market research coordinator, Ana Zatezalo, felt Quinntessential’s responsiveness and attitude towards new product enhancements was a key factor. She said:

We felt that from the contract negotiation stage through to final product training and product-related queries, Quinntessential showed a genuine willingness to work with SEEK to deliver the best possible solution to meet our needs. They made us feel that no request, however small, was too much trouble.

The Verdict:

Simon Waring, Communications Manager for SEEK Limited, believes that:

SEEK is a commercially focused, research driven organisation, and after we had made the practical decision to adopt the PeoplePulse tool following our review of the market, the transition was undoubtedly made even easier by the service and support our research team received.

Based on our experiences to date, I have no hesitation in recommending Quinntessential and PeoplePulse to any organisation looking to gather feedback using a user-friendly, feature-rich web-based survey tool.

More than 10 years on and SEEK Limited are still active users of the PeoplePulse tool, testiment to the quality of the solution and the support they have received over many years.


If you have a survey project, big or small, we'd love to hear from you ...

Here to help ...
How can we assist you? Drop us a note: